The following scene occurred a year or so ago:
Leslie enters a Victoria’s Secret, intent on redeeming her “Free Panty” card. Upon learning they only have white hipsters, size XS (Note: I’m referring to underwear, not people), Leslie saunters over to the fragrance wall and sprays herself with Rapture, her signature scent since 1998. A sale sign then lures her over to the lace thong section, where she discovers Hanky Panky knockoffs are on crazy sale – seven for $25. That’s cheaper than Tar-jay! Filled with cheapster’s glee, she begins sorting through the pretty colors. Sensing an easy commission, a salesgirl approaches…
VS Saleswoman: “Can I help you with anything?”
Leslie: “Oh, no, I’m OK, thanks. Just searching for the right size.”
VS Saleswoman: “I can help you with that. What size?”
Leslie: “Large.”
VS Saleswoman: “(Scanning my body up and down) “Are these for a friend?”
Leslie: “Um, no, for myself.”
VS Saleswoman: (Face wrinkling up like she just sucked a lemon) “Oh, no, you’re not a Large. Maybe a Small or Medium.”
Leslie: “No, I’m pretty sure I wear a Large. I’m wearing a pair from here as we speak and that’s what size they are.”
VS Saleswoman: (Again scanning my body vertically) “Wow, I would never have guessed that. You’re so skinny!”
Leslie: (grinning like a fool, realizing I now have something to blog about) “Well, I guess I’m a Skinny Large!”
Allow me to introduce you to the Skinny Large. Much like a teeny little bottle of fat-free butter spray can pack 900 calories, a Skinny Large is someone who wears a size that is, apparently, exponentially bigger than what she actually appears to be. I thought of this exchange when I read the recent New York Times article on vanity sizing, which revealed that a woman with a 27-inch waist wears an 8 or 10 at Marc Jacobs, but a 000 at Chico’s.
If that statement were a dress, it would be available in sizes “OMG,” “ROFL” and “WTF?”
Indeed, in my closet, I currently have a pair of size 13/14 army green cargo pants from H&M and a pair of size 4 black work trousers (oy, I’m so old) from New York & Co. Also: Size 6 and 8 pants from Express, Small sweaters from Anne Taylor Loft and XL sweaters from Nordstroms.
And while I’m loathe to admit it…guess which ones make me feel better about myself? When I go into a store and try on a medium, only to realize it’s too big, I feel a sick tinge of merriment when asingk the saleswoman, “This medium is too big. Can you grab me a small?” And when I struggle to shove my hips and ass into a size 12 pair of pants? I just want to flee like Christina Aguilera after her stage fall national anthem flub public drunkenness arrest I just want to leave.
That said, I’ve emotionally matured to a point where I don’t flee. If I really like the pants, I go up a size and purchase them anyways. My self-esteem no longer hinges on a clothing tag number; it’s just mildly influenced by it.
But would I want to step inside a mybestfit body scanning booth? Fully-clothed customers are scanned by hundreds of small antennas that quickly record 200,000+ points of measurement, emerging with a list of suggestions for brands and styles that would best suit their shape.
Personally, if I’m going to undergo a full-body scan, I’d like to know there’s a male TSA agent somewhere, gawking over and memorizing my every curve. Or I’d at least expect an MRI out of the deal. Some more suggestions on how mybestfit can improve its technology:
*Incorporate spray tan nozzles so you emerge both bronzed and size-enlightened.
*Wire the booth for surround sound and offer users the option to listen to body-positive affirmations recorded by Beyonce (“You’re body’s too bootylicious”), Brad Pitt, (“You’re so incredibly sexy. Come to Indonesia with me,”) or Tyra banks (“All the haters can kiss my fat ass!”)
*Pipe in the smell of money so customers feel richer and, therefore, more likely to drop $269 on a pair of J Brand jeans.





I just wrote about this today too. I would definitely use mybestfit.
Melissa – yep, I saw your post. The funny thing re your point that Old Navy and Banana Republic fit you so differently: They’re owned by the same freaking company! If anyone should have size cohesiveness, it’s them!
Huh. I could go for that. Drives me batty sometimes trying to find clothes. Even within single stores clothes will fit so randomly (Old Navy I’m looking at you!). I’d love a “map” to what would likely fit. But the suspicious part of me wonders if they aren’t compiling all those measurements for some (evil) purpose. : )
Ha! I went into Lane Bryant the other day. I’m a size sixeighteen. Yeah. My body and the fashion industry don’t agree. I heard about their color coded system for
bootyliciousunusual body types. I’m Tall.The associate told me she didn’t think I belonged in the store. She said that a plus fourteen would be too big for me. I think she really wanted to believe it herself. She went into full sell mode. It took me three different trips to get a pair of jeans that actually fit nicely. They never have the size/style I want in stock.
And they think I’m too
skinnysexy for their store.Yeah, that vanity sizing deal has gotten way out of hand. Back in the day (high school day, that is — in my case an excessively long time ago), I was all of 125 pounds at 5’9″, thought I was fat, and wore a size 12. Well all these many years later, I still wear a size 12. And I’m still 5’9″ (I may be old, but at least height shrinkage hasn’t set in yet). However, as my poor feet will attest, I’m a good (bad?) 35 pounds heavier than I was in my high school size 12.
P.S. WTF indeed!
Oh, TOTALLY – liz! I’m 5’10 and weighed 135 in high school but thought I was huge. I still have that weight on my driver’s license…
Journey – I ADORE that last strikethrough comment
Bdais – fab idea abut the map. They could sell them like they sell those maps of celebrity homes to tourists in Hollywood…
I hate clothes companies. I hate sizing for women. Why do men get to buy pants and shirts that are in actual inches based on actual sizes. 34 inch waist. 30 inch legs. 17 inch neck. For us it’s a freaking guessing game every.single.time.
I also feel better when a smaller size fits me, even though I clearly am the same size as I was….
I would totally use a body scanning booth to figure out my size! I have exactly ZERO jeans that fit me. And I own about 10 pairs. I would love a magical machine that would just tell me which pants to try on. That said, the number on the tag still does really affect me. Like you, I’ve gotten better about purchasing the size that fits me best (used to be that I wouldn’t buy something if I couldn’t buy it in the smallest size it came in) and now I have everything from XS to XL shirts in my closet. Baby steps?
Pingback: Why Facebook birthday wishes boost your body image | Nurture Principles
I would love to use that booth. It drives me crazy to have no idea what size I am and I’m not really a try on everything sort of girl. It seems to be totally random depending on the store…add in a long waist and short legs and I don’t shop much
Pingback: Stretching the Truth…or Why You’re Suddenly Size 2! – Simply Stated Blogs | Real Simple